Skip to content Skip to left sidebar Skip to right sidebar Skip to footer

Understanding the Concepts of “Constitution” and “Constitutional”

I. Introduction

In the realm of political science, law, and governance, the terms “Constitution” and “Constitutional” are often used interchangeably in everyday language. However, they carry distinct meanings and have specific legal and conceptual applications. Understanding their precise definitions and appropriate contexts is vital for legal practitioners, academicians, and students alike.

This article explores the definitions, differences, and practical usage of the terms Constitution and Constitutional, supported by illustrations and examples, especially in the Indian constitutional context.

Selective focus on flag, Indian constitution or Bharatiya Savidhana preamble old scattered text paper placed on Indian flag – Concept of Freedom, Nationality and patriotism

II. Definition of “Constitution”

The Constitution refers to the supreme law of the land, a formal document or set of fundamental principles that establish the framework of a government, enumerate the powers of its institutions, and guarantee rights to the people. It defines the structure, functions, and limitations of the organs of the state.

Legal Definition:

According to Article 1(1) of the Indian Constitution:

This clause is part of the Constitution, which contains the basic legal framework of the Republic of India.

Black’s Law Dictionary defines Constitution as:


Key Features of a Constitution:

  • Supreme and fundamental law
  • Lays down the structure of government
  • Allocates powers among various organs
  • Guarantees rights and liberties
  • Prescribes the process of amendment

Examples:

  • The Constitution of India (1950)
  • The Constitution of the United States (1789)
  • The Constitution of South Africa (1996)

III. Definition of “Constitutional”

The term Constitutional is an adjective derived from the noun Constitution. It means something that is in accordance with, or authorized by, the Constitution. It refers to laws, actions, or institutions that are compliant with or sanctioned by the provisions of the Constitution.

Legal Definition:

According to Merriam-Webster:

In legal parlance, constitutional refers to:

  • Laws or statutes enacted in accordance with constitutional provisions
  • Judicial interpretations regarding the constitutionality of legislative or executive actions
  • Rights and duties derived from the Constitution

Examples of Usage:

  • Constitutional Law – The body of law that interprets and implements the Constitution.
  • Constitutional Rights – Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution (e.g., Right to Equality under Article 14).
  • Constitutional Amendments – Changes or additions made to the Constitution through a specified procedure (e.g., 42nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1976).
  • Constitutional Crisis – A situation where the constitutional framework is challenged or under strain.

IV. Difference between “Constitution” and “Constitutional”

AspectConstitutionConstitutional
Part of SpeechNounAdjective
MeaningA formal document or system that lays down the fundamental laws of a nationPertaining to or consistent with the Constitution
FunctionIt is the source of legal authorityIt describes something as being in conformity with the Constitution
ExamplesConstitution of India, U.S. ConstitutionConstitutional rights, constitutional validity, constitutional amendment
ScopeStatic text/document with legal authorityDescriptive term for legality or conformity with constitutional principles

V. When to Use: Practical Usage and Illustrations

1. Use of “Constitution”:

Use “Constitution” when referring to the document, entity, or system itself.

Examples:

  • The Constitution of India came into force on 26 January 1950.
  • Every democratic country requires a written Constitution to govern effectively.
  • Amendments to the Constitution must follow Article 368.

2. Use of “Constitutional”:

Use “Constitutional” when describing rights, provisions, actions, or principles that are aligned with or derived from the Constitution.

Examples:

  • Article 21 provides the constitutional right to life and personal liberty.
  • The Supreme Court upheld the law as constitutional.
  • The President’s power to grant pardon is a constitutional authority.

VI. Legal Examples and Case Law Illustrations (Indian Context)

1. Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973)

  • Issue: Whether Parliament’s power to amend the Constitution is unlimited.
  • Held: The Supreme Court held that the Constitution has a “basic structure” that cannot be destroyed, even by constitutional amendment.
  • Illustration: The Court interpreted the constitutional validity of the 24th and 25th amendments.

2. Minerva Mills Ltd. v. Union of India (1980)

  • Held that certain amendments to the Constitution violated the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers and were therefore invalid.

3. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978)

  • Expanded the interpretation of constitutional rights under Article 21, linking it with Articles 14 and 19.

VII. Common Mistakes and Clarifications

VIII. Conclusion

While “Constitution” is the foundational document of a country, “constitutional” is an adjective used to describe anything that adheres to or is consistent with that document. Understanding this distinction is not merely academic but essential for correct legal and political discourse.

The Constitution is what governs, and constitutional is how things are governed in accordance with it.

To communicate with precision in the fields of law, governance, and civics, one must clearly differentiate between these two terms and use them in their appropriate contexts.

0 Comments

There are no comments yet

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *